Twelve homes

One brief, twelve answers. Master with a small closet and its own bath on the main floor; four kids' rooms and a shared room upstairs; open kitchen and dining, a living room, a laundry and a mud room; a kitchen for actually cooking in; an office right by the front door; 2000 sq ft or less.

    Why they look alike

    At this size the arithmetic is unforgiving. Four bedrooms, a loft and a bath need about 750 sq ft upstairs, which leaves about 1,190 for the main floor. The only way to fit everything in that is a two-storey body with a one-storey wing across the back: the living and dining room, the office, the hall and stair, the laundry and mud room in the body; the kitchen and the master suite in the wing, where they get their own outside walls and the master is away from the children's floor. Every home here is that massing. What changes between them is what a family would actually choose between: the width, which side things are on, the kind of kitchen, where the powder room is, whether the office has its own front door, which way the stair rises, the porches, and the roof.

    Upstairs is the same idea in every one, because it is the arrangement that fits: a loft at the top of the stair that is also the hall, two bedrooms down each side, the bath in the loft's wall.

    What the reviews changed, and what they did not

    Each layer โ€” the massing, the main floor, the upstairs, the kitchens and wet rooms, the roofs, this page โ€” was reviewed separately and the plans redrawn to it. Taken: the mud room opens straight onto the back hall instead of through the laundry; a coat closet at the front door; the office's own front door moved clear of its hall door; the master's door hung so it does not cover the closet; a real gap between the master's vanity and shower; sinks moved under windows and fridges out of corners; nothing standing in front of a bedroom door upstairs; bed heads on the end walls so no two children sleep head to head through one stud wall; a 4'6" tub where the bath is only 5' wide; every wing roof a simple shed at 2/12 that meets the body a foot below the upstairs sills, so no valley runs into the two-storey wall; porch roofs dropped to nine feet at the posts to clear the windows above; the saltbox's ridge moved forward so its back slope clears the back bedrooms' ceiling; the upstairs bath at the south end of its column so its stack lands in a solid stretch of wall.

    Not taken, on purpose. Which way the stair rises is a trade-off: toward the back it lands by the kitchen and the children come down past the master's door; toward the front it lands in the foyer and the coat closet is the one under the stair. Half the homes go each way. The kids' bath is one room, not a compartment: at 5'6" ร— 10'6" a separate toilet does not fit, and every home has a powder room downstairs. The 32' homes' living room is 188 sq ft; two feet of width is what they save. The wall that carries the loft upstairs sits over the living room's open floor and wants a flush beam; the low sheds want standing-seam metal and the shed-roofed home an unvented roof; every roof wants raised-heel trusses for the insulation, an attic hatch in the loft and one over the wing. None of that changes a plan.